Is the ECB’s monetary policy doomed to overshoot? Consequences of omitting owner-occupied housing from the HICP

Robert J. Hill
University of Graz

Miriam Steurer
University of Graz

Giang Nghiem
University of Hanover

Sofie R. Waltl
University of Cambridge

Random Order Applied

Abstract

The European Union has been debating for over 20 years how to bring owner-occupied housing (OOH) into the Harmonized Index of Consumer Prices (HICP ) – the flagship measure of inflation used by the European Central Bank (ECB) to set monetary policy. We provide a solution to this problem based on a smoothed version of the user-cost method that has desirable properties and does not destabilize the HICP . We then show how our extended HICP would have helped the ECB better anticipate shocks such as the 2022 inflation by causing measured inflation to rise above the 2% target sooner. Also, our measure aligns better with the inflation experienced by households.

JEL.: C31; C43; E01; E31; E52; R31

Keywords: Inflation measurement; Owner-occupied housing; Harmonized Index of Consumer Prices (HICP); Housing booms and busts; Inflation targeting; Leaning against the wind

Dissemination

Presentations (incl. scheduled): [Cambridge Real Estate Research Club at University of Cambridge] [3rd Workshop on Residential Housing Markets – A Market in Distress and Potential Solutions at WU Vienna] [14th European Meeting of the Urban Economics Association at Humboldt University Berlin] [First Oxford Real Estate Research Conference at Saïd Business School, University of Oxford][CERF Cavalcade, at Judge Business School, University of Cambridge][AREUEA International Conference, Barcelona][Society of Economic Measurement (SEM), Athens][School of Public Administration & Policy, Renmin University of China][International Symposium on Land and Real Estate Policy Research, Nanjing Agricultural University]